Blog
Fieldnotes
Informal communication about all areas of my professional work, from reflections on my ethnographic research experiences and updates on my academic activities, to posts focused on pedagogy and writing
How to Use a Dissertation Style Guide
Many doctoral students know how to navigate their discipline’s style guide, but they do not always know that they are required to follow their university’s style guide or their program’s dissertation style guide as well. This blog both explains how a discipline’s style guide works with a dissertation style guide and outlines some of the advice I’ve given to doctoral students in the writing center for using these two guides together.
Literature Reviews are Epistemological, Not Just Technical
While literature reviews can look different in each discipline, the technical questions related to them reveal shared epistemological concerns.
Literature Reviews Signal Relationships, Camps, and Alliances
References and citations are more than technical; rather, their presence signals relationships, camps, and alliances. Who doctoral students cite reveals much about their academic training and perceived place in the discipline.
Literature Reviews Reveal the Real People Behind the Discourse
Disciplines are built around specific topics and interpretive paradigms, but these ideas do not develop on their own. People are always behind them.
Literature Reviews Deploy Theory Instead of Reconstructing It
Literature reviews are rarely just a summary of existing literature; instead, literature reviews are argumentative—they often deploy a discourse to make a point instead of reconstruct a discourse.
Literature Reviews Disclose Existing Conversations
Correctly citing secondary sources is more than a mere technicality. Instead, it is about demonstrating the academic labor of others.
Framing Literature Reviews as Historiography
When doctoral students write literature reviews, they need to make clear not only what connections are being made, but also who is making them. The concept of historiography can help frame this aspect of writing literature reviews.
How Much Is Too Much? Balancing Citations within Prose
Finding a balance between talking about other people’s work and your own analysis in an essay can be hard. You want to demonstrate that you’ve done the research necessary to support your points but avoid accusations of plagiarism. What balance should you strike? Here are four questions to ask yourself to determine whether or not you need more citations—or if you have too many.
Dissertation Literature Reviews: How Do I Write One?
We have talked about why literature reviews are important to the academic endeavor, looked at what components a literature review has, and discussed how to determine its intellectual quality. Now that we understand literature reviews as a genre, we can get practical: how do we write a literature review?
Dissertation Literature Reviews: What Components Does a Good Lit Review Have?
The previous blog post in this series talked about why literature reviews are important to the academic endeavor and how the process itself makes a person into a credible scholar and a researcher. This blog post looks at the components of a literature review and discuss how to evaluate its contents.
Dissertation Literature Reviews: What Are They, and What’s the Big Deal?
A good dissertation literature review is much more than a technical exercise. The process of constructing a lit review initiates you into your discipline’s practices, making you into a scholar and researcher in your field and establishing the value of your own research.
When your dissertation turns out really different from your proposal
Changes to dissertation research are expected. In fact, these changes can make your project better.